Village
Code 2-45 defines Decorum. Meetings have
now deteriorated to the point where it is now read prior to each meeting.
Shelley Stanczyk even brought it up for lesson at the Committee of the Whole
workshop held Wednesday, July 18. She asked for more civility and particularly
“to stop calling people out” or venting. Clearly the Mayor’s lesson, in
practice, was lay off the Mayor, Vice mayor and Councilwoman from district 3,
but the other two are fair and appropriate game. I was disappointed to see Mrs. Stanczyk allow
two separate speakers, coincidentally, both board members of the CCOCI to
praise her, the vice mayor and council woman Lindsay, but then allow both
speakers to personally admonish and ‘call out’ Howard Tendrich and Patrick
Fiore in direct contradiction to her pleas made less than an hour earlier in
the very same meeting. Has she no recall
of what she preached earlier or does the Mayor’s call for civility apply only to
her and not to the two dissenters on the Palmetto Bay council? Perhaps it was because these two council
members crossed the CCOCI party line and failed to continue to support endless
litigation. The two speakers can be viewed on the village
web cast (1:57:45) and (2:04:09).
I ask
that Shelley Stanczyk please take the time to actually read Village
Code 2-45. It provides that all speakers must address their remarks to the
mayor, speak in a dignified and courteous manner, and avoid admonishing
individual members of the public, council and representatives of the village. This is not what occurred however, when the
CCOCI officers spoke.
Shelley
Stanczyk failed to once again follow the long standing code for decorum and
allowed personal attacks to be launched against the two council members who
ironically were correct in their following of the law, but were nonetheless
improperly ‘called out’ for failing to listen to the ‘will of the people’ and
creating a ‘banana republic.’ Both Howard Tendrich and Patrick Fiore were judged
ultimately correct in trying to follow the law, but they were one vote short.
Had any of the other 3 on the council followed their vote and direction, and
the advice of private legal counsel, the appeals would have ended much earlier
and without imposition of fees and costs imposed against the village taxpayers
which has still yet to be calculated.
I was
personally shocked and would respectfully disagree stating that no, CCOCI board
members, I believe you have it backwards. A “banana republic” is created and
maintained when government officials and a minority of residents refuse to act
within the rule of law and that government and its official cater to the will
of a small ‘ruling class’ in opposition to the general public.
Kudos to
both Howard Tendrich and Patrick Fiore for not engaging and making the
situation even worse. Shame on Shelley Stanczyk for not making it through even
one meeting trying to change a lack of decorum situation. Respect is earned.
Shelley Stanczyk should not continue to maintain a double standard, one that
chastises those who disagree with her, while allowing negative personal
comments against those on the council who may publicly disagree with her.
Please view another
blog that I think has properly framed the issue, South Dade Matters, in
a July 18, 2012, post “PB: NPO and Decorum” which raised the issue:
Will Mayor Stanczyk address the decorum of her minions who sit in
the back of the chamber and heckle anyone with whom they disagree? Go to the
video of the last council meeting at
1:07:39 to hear the ugly,
empowered mob heckle a resident into silence. SDM notes that Mayor Stanczyk
reprimanded the audience generally for their hostility towards the speaker.
Yet, SDM understands – and is willing to be corrected if wrong –
that a family member of the Mayor participates in this practice. There is no doubt that most of the hecklers
howl only when the Mayor’s, the Vice Mayor’s and Councilwoman Lindsay’s
opponents are speaking.
SDM Wonders: Is the Mayor tacitly endorsing this
repulsive behavior when she fails to discipline her admirers? Decorum cuts both
ways – or at least it should.
(Emphasis added) (and
further note that in my opinion, the reprimanding was done long after it
occurred)
The banana label was
clearly misapplied on July 18, 2012.
Gene you continue to amaze in that you seem to expect something different from madam mayor. She is all about friends and family. She has no regard for other opinions.
ReplyDeleteCCOCI needs to reach deep into their own pockets and collect money to reimburse Palmetto Bay for this foolishness. Can the village sue CCOCI?
ReplyDeleteIronic Gene. Didn't one of the same CCOCI speakers pen a letter to soapbox criticizing you for your comments made to the council? That letter now seems very hypocritical to me.
ReplyDeleteThere is a golden rule for Mayor Stanczyk, but not the one you referred to. Her rule is: "She who has the gold makes the rules". She is the classic bully. I watched the tape. I was amazed to see how she actually let speakers attack the only two officials who have been right and who have been the only two to actually both 'for the people.' And my comments for those two? They are the ones creating the corrupt banana republic.
ReplyDeleteWhere can I find a petition to sign?